Childhood, Crafts, Family, Humor, Link Party, Motherhood

There’s Something Fishy About These Valentines. Get It? Fishy?

School of Fish Valentines- Perfect for Preschoolers!
I had found these adorable Valentine’s on Pinterest a while back and then I went to the blog where I pinned it from here.
It turns out that she got the idea from an Etsy shop, but the link she provided didn’t lead to anything.
So I went to Etsy and searched for Valentine + Fish + Bowl and it came up with five different shops who sell almost the same item.
I just picked the first one I saw, which happened to be this shop here.
This is the thing: they don’t sell anything but the printable you put INSIDE the bag.
You have to purchase everything else.
So I thought, I think I can do this on the cheap.
Will it look as professional as the Etsy ones?
But it’s for my daughter’s preschool class, so I don’t want it to look professional.
Because, you know.
She’s five.

This is what you will need:

– Swedish Fish (Wal-Mart has them in the candy aisle)
– Clear round bags (Michael’s has them in the candy making aisle)
– Blue scrapbook paper

Then, take a rusty circle cookie cutter.
Oh okay, I guess it doesn’t have to be rusty.
Trace a circle onto the blue scrapbook paper.


Then I took a red sharpie marker and wrote the above on it.
Clever, huh?
School of fish/ preschool?
I saw this idea on Etsy or something like it so I cannot take credit for this.


The following is the brutal honesty I am known for here on my blog.
It is no secret in these parts that I have some remedial skills that are lacking.
I have the handwriting of a serial killer, my cursive is a hybrid of cursive and block letter and I cannot cut a straight line to save my life.

Valentine fish

All me.
Not the preschooler, but for me.
She actually cuts better than I do.

Valentine fish

Don’t forget to make a Valentine for the teachers too!!

Isn’t that cute?
But it needed a little something…..


I have a “thing” for little hands creating projects.



Oops, now everyone knows what they are getting for Valentines Day.
Act surprised when it comes in the mail. 


So the Etsy paper insert ranged from $3.50 to $6.00 for a pack of only five inserts.

But here is my cost rundown:

– scrapbook paper = 50 cents ( I got mine at Michael’s and they had a 50% off sale when I bought these)

– Swedish fish = $6.00 for 3 packages (Walmart)

– clear baggies = $4.99 regular price at Michael’s. But 100 come in the package so I know I will use these for something else. If you are smart, you will use the weekly coupon that comes in Michael’s ads for 40% off a regular price item which will make this $2.00 cheaper

Grand total = $11.49 to create 20 homemade Valentines
Which breaks down to 57 cents a Valentine!


If I had purchased the Etsy inserts, it would have cost me $25 more which I would never have spent.
I mean come on, it’s Valentines for a preschooler.
I probably won’t do this again but this is her first year of school and wanted to make her Valentine exchange a little special.
Next year I am sure we will be buying Spongebob Valentines from Dollar Tree.

So what do you think?
It took us all of 45 minutes to create 20 Valentines start to finish but it looks like it took a lot longer.
I am sure I will get evil death stares on the faces of the other preschool moms for making these.
That’s okay I will return the favor in kindergarten.

14 thoughts on “There’s Something Fishy About These Valentines. Get It? Fishy?”

  1. That is really, so awfully cute! But I just paid $3.50 at the grocery store for 28 Disney Princess Valentines with a castle-shaped lollipop. I'm not ashamed.Love your clever "school" comments! 🙂


  2. I had nightmares last night and I am blaming them all on GoDaddy. Ick!The valentines are fantastic. If it makes you feel any better, I suck at cutting, too.


  3. I had nightmares last night and I'm blaming it all on GoDaddy. Ick!If it makes you feel any better, I suck at cutting, too. I don't think I have the patience for it. And, yes, I recognize how sad that sounds.


  4. Too cute of a craft. Unfortunately, they wont let the kids bring treats in 1st grade or I'd be rocking these for Princess M. Maybe they make fish erasers . . . . .


  5. I wish my son still did Valentine's. I always loved getting them ready for him and then going through them with him when he got home from school. He's too old for all that fun stuff now!


  6. So you’re just cutting circles out on paper, writing a message, and then putting it in a bag with candy? Pretty clever. All the other kids are just getting a card, right? Ha! Yours will be the best. The other mothers will get you back.


    1. They will and they have! I am now heading to Dollar Tree and buying the store kind because it isn’t “cool” to have handmade Valentines!
      Hooray! 😉


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s